Saturday, May 21, 2022

Paleontologists Found the Jaws of an Extremely Rare Bear in Tavrida

The bones of an Etruscan bear in the cave were discovered by Dmitry Gimranov and Aleksandr Lavrov.
 Photo: Anastasia Mavrenkova

Ural paleontologists discovered the lower jaws of an Etruscan bear from the Early Pleistocene (2-1.5 million years ago) in the Taurida Cave (Crimean Peninsula). The finding is extremely important, because it is rare and indicates that the territory of Crimea almost 2 million years ago, most likely lived an ancestor of modern man, early Homo. Scientists reported the finding in the international journal of paleobiology Historical Biology.

Remains of Etruscan bears (which is the ancestor of brown and cave bears) as part of the fauna of large mammals of the Early Pleistocene were found in Western Europe, in Asia, as well as in North Africa, but not in Russia. The fact is that in Russia, Early Pleistocene faunas with remains of large terrestrial vertebrates were practically not known before. Crimea in this regard is an attractive and informative place for scientists.

"Our finding, on the one hand, extends the geography of the distribution of the Etruscan bear in Eastern Europe, and on the other hand, indicates that the "Crimean" bear is a link between Asian and European counterparts. It also helps to characterize the evolutionary features within bears and the historical biogeography of this species," says Dmitry Gimranov, senior researcher at the Laboratory of Natural Science Methods in Humanities at Ural Federal University and the Paleoecology Institute of Plant and Animal Ecology, Ural Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences.

Archaeological digs were conducted by paleontologists in 2020-2021. The remains were found in the pre-surface layer of Tavrida sediments, in a small chamber called "Hyena's Den". The research was conducted over the year. As a result, it was found that the Etruscan bear coexisted next to such large predators as lynxes, giant hyenas, saber-toothed cats and wolves, with whom it had to compete for food resources just as it probably did with humans.

"More than 2 million years ago, together with the fauna of that time - antelopes, bulls, elephants, hyenas, Etruscan bears - ancient Homo man moved towards Eurasia. Generally, the presence of members of these faunas in the territories of Western Europe correlates with the presence of ancient Homo. We have not found the remains of ancient humans in Tavrida, most likely they were there, we just have not found them yet. "However, the structure of fauna of the cave Tavrida - Etruscan bear, saber-toothed tigers, hyenas and other large mammals - suggests that at this time in this area could pass migration routes of ancient people," says Dmitry Gimranov.

The Etruscan bear was a typical representative of European fauna during the early Homo period, scientists believe. They drew their conclusion by comparing finds from the Tavrida Cave and its closest point with the same fauna of the same age in Dmanisi, Georgia, where the earliest Eurasian Homo remains have been found.

It is noted that scientists from the Ural Federal University, the Institute of Plant and Animal Ecology, Ural Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Paleontological Institute, Russian Academy of Sciences, and the Autonomous University of Barcelona took part in the study. In the next phase of work, paleontologists plan to study the food habits and ecological characteristics of Etruscan bears. This will help to understand how they competed for food resources with other large predators.


The Tavrida Cave was discovered in Crimea in 2018. It is located 15 km east of Simferopol on the Inner Ridge of the Crimean Mountains; it was formed in sediments of Paleogene nummulite limestone. The bone layer of the cave corresponds to the fauna of Eastern Europe and the Late Villafranc of Western Europe (about 1.8-1.5 million years). Tavrida is rich in bones of early Pleistocene mammals. Thus, during two seasons of excavations, paleontologists found there the remains of two individuals of the Isuar lynx (relatively young and old), the skull of the giant Hyena Pachycrocuta and bones of other ancient animals.

Homo is a genus in the family Hominidae, which includes Homo sapiens and closely related extinct species. The oldest representatives of the subfamily Hominin appeared about 2.5 million years ago. They are often referred to as "Early Homo" emphasizing their resemblance to humans and their distinction from apes. The first true humans were archanthropes. The difference between archanthropes and modern humans is striking, so many anthropologists distinguish a special genus Pithecanthropes for them. The last "renewal" in the genus Homo was Denisovites - people whose remains were found in Denisov cave in Altai.

Source/Credit: Ural Federal University