. Scientific Frontline: Voltage-Driven Nonequilibrium Hall Effect Without Magnets

Friday, November 20, 2026

Voltage-Driven Nonequilibrium Hall Effect Without Magnets

The concentric loops illustrate how two electronic Fermi surfaces
The concentric loops illustrate how two electronic Fermi surfaces—the momentum-space states most responsive to voltage—stretch and distort as an applied electric field increases. Dashed lines show their undisturbed equilibrium shapes, while progressively larger solid loops trace their deformation under stronger fields.
Image Credit: Rice University/Shouvik Sur

Scientific Frontline: Extended "At a Glance" Summary
: Voltage-Driven Nonequilibrium Hall Effect

The Core Concept: Theoretical physicists led by Qimiao Si of Rice University and first author Shouvik Sur, a former Rice postdoctoral fellow, have proposed a new Hall transport regime—termed the "fully nonequilibrium response"—to explain anomalous experimental measurements obtained with collaborators at the Technical University of Vienna. Above a material-specific applied voltage threshold, a nonmagnetic, strongly correlated topological semimetal generates a perpendicular electric current that mimics the linear Hall transport signature of broken time-reversal symmetry (TRS) without an external magnetic field or internal magnetism.

Key Distinction/Mechanism: In the classical Hall effect (driven by an external magnetic field) and anomalous Hall regimes (driven by internal magnetism), broken TRS yields a transverse Hall response that scales linearly with the longitudinal electrical drive. In a nonmagnetic, strongly correlated topological semimetal under weak electrical drive, TRS remains unbroken and the transverse Hall voltage scales quadratically with the longitudinal current. When the applied voltage exceeds a material-dependent threshold, however, the electric field accelerates charge carriers and shifts the system into a reversible, voltage-driven nonequilibrium state in which the transverse Hall response scales linearly with the longitudinal drive—mimicking the transport signature of broken TRS until the voltage decreases and nonlinear scaling resumes. Notably, the university release describes this mechanism in general terms without identifying the specific experimental compound or reporting measurement conditions such as temperature and voltage scales.

Origin/History: First discovered in the late nineteenth century, the Hall effect was subsequently expanded to include anomalous, quantum, and nonlinear variants governed by internal magnetism, quantum mechanics, and electronic band topology. This work builds on an earlier theoretical proposal for a strongly correlated topological semimetal state developed by Si's group at Rice University and investigated experimentally with collaborators at the Technical University of Vienna, though the source release does not name the specific quantum phase or material realization.

Major Frameworks/Components:

  • TRS Transport Scaling: Within near-equilibrium, weak-drive transport, the scaling between the transverse Hall response and the longitudinal electrical drive diagnoses TRS, with linear scaling indicating broken TRS and quadratic scaling (transverse voltage proportional to longitudinal current squared) indicating unbroken TRS.
  • Two-Stage Crossover from Nonlinear to Linear Hall Transport: Increasing the applied voltage drives a strongly correlated topological semimetal from a below-threshold, weak-drive nonlinear Hall regime across a material-dependent transition point—ranging from very low to higher voltages depending on the compound—into an above-threshold, strong-drive linear regime.
  • Momentum-Space Electron Shift: An applied electric field above a material-dependent threshold significantly displaces the charge-carrier distribution in momentum space, pushing the strongly correlated topological semimetal beyond perturbative equilibrium into a reversible nonequilibrium state that subsides when the field is reduced.

Branches of Science: Condensed Matter Physics, Quantum Materials Physics, Solid-State Physics, Nonequilibrium Statistical Mechanics, and Materials Science.

Future Application: Researchers can use this nonequilibrium framework to interpret transport measurements in equilibrium quantum states of matter and to gather supporting diagnostic evidence for strongly correlated topological semimetal phases in candidate materials. Its immediate utility remains foundational, with no near-term device or technological applications reported in the release.

Why It Matters: Traditionally, physicists have analyzed the Hall effect within equilibrium physics under weak external forces, where a linear Hall signal serves as a standard indicator of magnetic TRS breaking. Demonstrating that an applied voltage alone can drive a nonmagnetic system out of equilibrium to mimic the linear Hall signature of broken TRS shows that linear scaling does not uniquely signify broken TRS beyond weak-field equilibrium. Linking nonequilibrium charge-carrier dynamics to equilibrium electronic structure provides an additional analytical framework for studying strongly correlated quantum materials, though generalizing the mechanism will require experimental validation across additional compounds and careful exclusion of confounding nonequilibrium artifacts such as Joule heating.

The Hall effect—a physical phenomenon discovered by Edwin Hall in 1879 in which a transverse voltage or current develops perpendicular to an applied electric field or longitudinal current—remains a foundational probe in condensed matter physics. Over the past century, physicists have expanded this framework to encompass quantum and anomalous regimes that emerge under nonclassical conditions. In a theoretical study published November 18, 2026, in Physical Review Letters, Shouvik Sur, Lei Chen, Yiming Wang, Chandan Setty, Silke Paschen, and Qimiao Si described a fully nonequilibrium (FNE) Hall response that operates outside conventional linear-response frameworks.

The research team spans Rice University, Stony Brook University, Iowa State University, Ames National Laboratory, and the Institute of Solid State Physics at the Vienna University of Technology (TU Wien). Their theoretical framework was motivated by earlier experimental observations of an unexplained zero-field Hall signal in the strongly correlated topological semimetal Ce3Bi4Pd3.

“Our work epitomizes how research often spirals upward,” said Si, a professor of physics and astronomy at Rice University and the study’s corresponding author. “It can be traced back to a theoretical proposal for a strongly correlated topological semimetal state that my group advanced previously.”

An Unexplained Signal in a Weyl–Kondo Semimetal

Strongly correlated topological semimetals are quantum materials in which strong electron-electron interactions coexist with topologically protected electronic band crossings. The experimental realization at the center of this work is Ce3Bi4Pd3 (cerium–bismuth–palladium), a noncentrosymmetric, nonsymmorphic heavy-fermion Weyl–Kondo semimetal that breaks spatial inversion symmetry while preserving microscopic time-reversal symmetry (TRS).

In a 2021 experimental study published in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, collaborators at TU Wien and Rice University measured electrical transport in Ce3Bi4Pd3 alongside the nonmagnetic metallic reference compound La3Bi4Pd3. Below a single-ion Kondo temperature of 13 K, Ce3Bi4Pd3 crosses over into a Kondo-coherent regime below approximately 7 K, reaching full Kondo coherence below 2.5 K (with a characteristic scaling field of 10 T).

Below 3 K—and in zero applied magnetic field (0 T)—the material exhibited a giant spontaneous Hall effect, with harmonic current-scaling measurements performed down to 1.7 K under both direct current (DC) and alternating current (AC) excitations. Under an AC driving current at fundamental frequency 1ω, the measurements simultaneously revealed spontaneous transverse Hall voltages in the second-harmonic (2ω) channel, the rectified DC (0ω) channel, and the first-harmonic (1ω) channel, with the Hall angle per applied electric field reaching up to 3 × 10−3 m/V in the 2ω channel under small applied electric fields. While the 2ω signal confirmed the expected topological Berry curvature of the Weyl–Kondo state, the linear 1ω response presented a central puzzle.

Rethinking Time-Reversal Symmetry in Hall Transport

In the classical Hall effect, passing an electric current through a conductor or semiconductor exposed to a perpendicular magnetic field deflects charge carriers via the Lorentz force, generating a transverse voltage or current perpendicular to both the driving current and the magnetic field. Under TRS, the physical dynamics of a system remain unchanged if the direction of time is mathematically reversed. Because reversing time flips the direction of electric currents and magnetic fields, an external magnetic field or internal magnetism breaks TRS; in nonmagnetic materials without an applied magnetic field, TRS is preserved.

In the anomalous Hall effect, internal magnetism breaks TRS and generates a transverse Hall response without an external magnetic field. In its quantized counterpart, the quantum anomalous Hall effect, this transverse conductance takes discrete quantized values carried by dissipationless chiral edge states.

Physicists routinely test for TRS breaking by analyzing how the transverse Hall signal scales with the longitudinal driving electric field or current. As first author Shouvik Sur explained, a linear proportionality between the transverse Hall response and the longitudinal drive (producing a 1ω signal under AC excitation) is conventionally treated as a diagnostic signature of broken TRS. Conversely, in a nonmagnetic material that lacks spatial inversion symmetry while preserving TRS, the leading Hall signal is expected to follow a quadratic, nonlinear scaling (producing a 2ω signal) in which the transverse response is proportional to the square of the longitudinal drive. Because Ce3Bi4Pd3 possesses neither internal magnetism nor an applied magnetic field, the observed linear 1ω Hall signature appeared to contradict equilibrium transport theory.

A Two-Stage Nonequilibrium Mechanism

To resolve this contradiction, the researchers modeled both DC and AC spatially uniform electric fields using a Boltzmann kinetic framework incorporating a field- and momentum-dependent electron relaxation time. Their analysis showed that the material’s quantum nonlinear anomalous Hall effect—a quantum-geometric transport phenomenon rooted in electronic Berry curvature—exhibits a two-stage response as the driving electric field increases.

In the weak-field, perturbative stage, the transverse Hall current is governed by the Berry curvature dipole and scales quadratically with the applied electric field, consistent with preserved TRS. At stronger, nonperturbative electric fields, however, the applied field shifts the electron distribution substantially in momentum space past the separation between the Fermi surface and the peaks of the Berry curvature density. In this second stage, the response is no longer controlled by the Berry curvature dipole alone; higher multipoles of the Berry curvature contribute, and the field-driven asymmetry in the relaxation time generates a quasi-linear, first-harmonic (1ω) Hall current that mimics broken TRS even though microscopic TRS remains intact.

This high-drive FNE regime is fully reversible: once the applied electric field decreases, the electron distribution relaxes and the material reverts to its conventional quadratic, TRS-preserving Hall response. According to Sur, the crossover threshold between the quadratic and linear regimes depends strongly on the electronic structure of the material. In strongly correlated Weyl–Kondo semimetals such as Ce3Bi4Pd3, strong electron-electron interactions renormalize quasiparticle velocities by roughly a factor of 1,000 relative to a simple metal, producing a very small Fermi surface with Berry curvature peaks located close to the Fermi level. Because of these compressed energy and momentum scales, even modest applied electric fields can push the material into the FNE regime, whereas weakly correlated materials require much higher fields.

Whereas conventional Hall theory relies on near-equilibrium, weak-field linear-response physics, the newly described FNE regime reflects strong-field, far-from-equilibrium transport driven directly by an applied electric field.

“Here, we found something that can look like magnetism in an equilibrium system, something we understand quite well, but it is not magnetism, and it is not in an equilibrium system,” Sur said.

Implications and Experimental Considerations

Characterizing this nonequilibrium crossover refines how physicists interpret the quantum nonlinear anomalous Hall effect and establishes a theoretical foundation for using strong-field transport to probe the equilibrium electronic topology of strongly correlated semimetals. Published in the same issue of Physical Review Letters, a companion theoretical paper by Lei Geng, Martin Eckstein, Chen, Sur, Paschen, Si, and Philipp Werner further examines nonperturbative nonlinear Hall transport in nonequilibrium steady states.

“Our work supports the existence of a strongly correlated topological semimetal state,” Si said. “It demonstrates how studying nonequilibrium quantum phenomena can deepen our understanding of quantum states of matter in equilibrium.”

Applying this framework across condensed matter experiments requires careful experimental controls. At elevated driving voltages and currents, distinguishing intrinsic nonequilibrium momentum-space shifts from confounding artifacts—such as Joule heating and extrinsic disorder scattering—remains essential, alongside testing the two-stage crossover across additional nonmagnetic quantum materials.

Funding: The work at Rice University was supported by the National Science Foundation (DMR-2220603), the Robert A. Welch Foundation (C-1411), and the Office of Naval Research (ONR) Vannevar Bush Faculty Fellowship (ONR-VB N00014-23-1-2870). Collaborator Silke Paschen acknowledged support from the European Union through the European Research Council (ERC, CorMeTop, project 101055088), the German Research Foundation (Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft, DFG), and the Austrian Science Fund (FWF) via project FOR 5249 (QUAST).

Published in journal: Physical Review Letters

Title: Fully Nonequilibrium Hall Response from Berry Curvature

Authors: Shouvik Sur, Lei Chen, Yiming Wang, Chandan Setty, Silke Paschen, and Qimiao Si

Source/Credit: Rice University

Edited by: Scientific Frontline

Reference Number: phy112026_01

Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Contact Us

Featured Article

What Is: The Minimal Genome and Synthetic Evolution

Scientific Frontline: Extended "At a Glance" Summary : The Minimal Genome and Synthetic Evolution The Core Concept : Researchers h...

Top Viewed Articles